The successful resection of a supratentorial
glioma without further increase in the pre-existing neurological
deficit of the patient is among the most difficult of all
neurosurgical exercises. Significant palliation with good
functional recovery cannot be achieved on a routine basis unless
the surgeon undertakes such procedures with the same seriousness
of purpose and attention to detail more commonly lavished upon
less frequent disorders. It is my belief that optimal results
are achieved when maximal resection of the tumor has been
combined with minimal disturbance of the surrounding brain.
Careful preoperative planning, scrupulous surgical technique,
and the selective use of such aids as the operating microscope
and the carbon dioxide laser all play a role in the gentle
removal of the tumor and the fastidious preservation of adjacent
nervous tissue. It is now possible to safely remove large glial
tumors from virtually any hemispheric location without
significant impairment of the patient. Radical removal
accomplishes several goals for the oncologist-surgeon: (1)
adequate sampling of the tissue for histopathologic study and
diagnosis; (2) maximal mechanical cytoreduction of the tumor
mass prior to the institution of other forms of therapy; (3)
immediate relief from elevated ICP, permitting adequate
exposure of the patient to other treatments; and (4) the removal
of cells known to be insensitive to other treatment modalities. Because the length of survival of patients with
gliomas can be correlated with the extent of the surgical
resection, it is common policy to offer radical removal
to all patients in whom an acceptable level of function can be
predicted. As with other operations, the number of such patients
tends to increase as the skill, experience, and judgment of the
surgeon grow. Nevertheless, there remain some patients for whom
a radical resection is an inappropriate procedure, and
reasonable alternatives are considered.
Preoperative planning begins with a careful
review of the neurological findings, the functional status of
the patient, and the relevant features of the enhanced CT or
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans. The general condition of
the patient, the presence or absence of specific neurological deficits, the
prospects for useful recovery, and the precise location of the
lesion all have considerable bearing upon the selection of a
specific operative approach. For example, a tumor located
close to a cortical surface is generally attacked through that
surface if the associated cortical function is already lost and
the prospect for its recovery is small, or if the potential loss
of function (e.g., quadrantanopsia or weakness restricted to the
distal leg) is considered justified by both patient and
physician in view of the potential gains of the procedure.
Once the general approach has been chosen,
rational design of an appropriate scalp incision and bone flap
may proceed; it is highly preferable for these matters to be
decided prior to the day of surgery, The surgeon should measure
the maximum extent of the lesion in the vertical, transverse,
and rostrocaudal directions as it appears on the enhanced CT or
MRI scans, remembering to use the appropriate conversion factor
to obtain the true physical dimensions in centimetres; the
resection cavity obtained at the end of the operation must also
be measured and should not exceed in any direction the
preoperative radiographic estimates.
It is important for the
surgeon to develop the capacity of forming a mental image of
the three-dimensional extent of the lesion in such a way as to
be capable of visualizing the spatial relationships of the
lesion to the anatomic structures that surround it. It is
especially critical for the surgeon, in both planning and
conducting the resection of a supratentorial glioma, to be able
to perceive the location of the tumor vis-a-vis the motor strip,
the thalamus, the basal ganglia, the lateral ventricle, the
angular gyrus, the superior temporal lobe, the tentorial
incisura, the falx, the pterion, the coronal suture, and the
external ear. In forming this three-dimensional concept of the
tumor and its surrounding structures, the surgeon relies most on
the preoperative enhanced CT and MRI scans, and a knowledge of
normal anatomy. An arteriogram is usually not necessary in the
preoperative evaluation of a patient with a supratentorial
glioma, but if it is available, the relationship of the tumor to
the superficial cortical veins is useful information. The
cortical veins are sometimes visible by magnetic resonance
angiography (MRV), and the relationship of the tumor to the
motor strip can be judged on the preoperative MRI views. The
surgeon should have all such information in mind when the
operation begins, to facilitate an extensive but safe tumor
resection. It is all too easy for the unprepared surgeon to
become lost within the substance of the brain and to wander inadvertently into areas that preclude
the successful recovery of the patient.
A few words are in order concerning the
premedication of the patient. All
glioma patients are put on glucocorticosteroids and prophylactic
anticonvulsants. Because transcortical approaches are required
in virtually all glial tumors, it is vitally important to
minimize the amount of postoperative somnolence, brain swelling,
and seizure activity. A minimum of 2 to 3 days of dexamethasone
(4 to 10 mg every 4 to 6 h) or an equivalent dose of
methylprednisolone is required to adequately prepare the brain
for surgery. Aggressive use of corticosteroids and good
neuroanesthesia can avoid unnecessary intraoperative
administration of mannitol or ethacrinic acid. Several days
should also be allowed for preoperative loading of
anticonvulsants; sodium phenytoin is the preferred drug because
it does not cause central nervous system (CNS) depression at
therapeutic levels and because it can be given intravenously
during the operation. Patients who have not received adequate
amounts of anticonvulsants may suffer a seizure during emergence
from anaesthesia, and the associated motor activity and systemic
hypertension pose serious threats to haemostasis and relaxation
at the operative site. Many postoperative problems can be
avoided by careful preoperative planning and close
communication between the surgeon and the neuroanesthesiologist.
All patients are operated on under general
anaesthesia. Airway management and intubation must be smooth so
as not to produce elevations in the ICP or sudden bleeding
within the tumor. Proper positioning of the patient is essential
in producing a relaxed brain and a relaxed surgeon. The major
axis of the tumor should lie in a plane parallel to the floor of
the operating theatre. The head of the patient is slightly
elevated above the level of the chest to promote venous
drainage; for similar reasons, extreme rotation of the neck is
avoided, as is extreme forward flexion. The majority of glial
tumors can be operated on in the supine position and in an
ordinary headrest; this is especially the case for many frontal
and temporal and some parietal lesions. When the major axis of
the tumor requires that the patient be placed in a full
lateral, three-quarter prone, or semi sitting position, secure
fixation in head pins is always employed; this situation is
frequently encountered with high parietal, posterior temporal,
true occipital, parapineal, and paramidline tumors. The line of
incision is always marked, even for reoperations, because the
combination of an iodine preparation and a plastic drape will
usually obscure the old incision scar as well as all superficial
landmarks. A prophylactic antibiotic should be administered
just prior to making the incision.
In general, operations for
tumor require much larger craniotomies than procedures carried
out in similar locations for cerebrovascular, infective, or
traumatic diseases. Retraction can be quite difficult during
tumor surgery, and some provision must be made for swollen
brain. In addition, the exposure must be large enough and
versatile enough to permit a change in either the angle of
attack or the general nature of the procedure (e.g.,
intratumoral resection as opposed to lobectomy). In other words,
although radical intratumoral resection is sufficient in most
cases, the incision is planned as if a major lobectomy might
have to be carried out. For frontal lobe tumors, the incision
must give access to the frontal pole, the pterion, the orbital
plate, the sphenoid wing, and the midline. Anterior
temporal lobe tumors are best approached through a question
mark-shaped incision that begins on the zygoma, just anterior to
the ear, and curves forward above the superior temporal line
until it meets the external orbital angle.
Incisions close to the ear spare the main trunk of the
superficial temporal artery and the superior branch of the
facial nerve. Posterior temporal lobe and inferior parietal lobe
lesions require a formal temporal craniotomy, either through a
reverse question mark- or through a horseshoe-shaped incision.
The posterior limb of the incision comes down at or just behind
the interaural line and should not reach the asterion. The latter is however, the most anterior and inferior
point of large occipital horseshoe flaps, the mesial limb of
which may reach the posterior midline. Parietal flaps are
almost always made as horseshoe incisions, the apex just
touching or crossing the sagittal suture; the base of the flap
is at the level of the superior temporal line. All
the standard incisions are planned in such a way as to provide
access to important anatomic landmarks with preservation of the
superficial blood supply as it enters the flap from the inferior
margin. Fresh incisions are infiltrated with a mixture of lidocaine and epinephrine to prevent blood loss and undue
traumatization of the scalp from clips and cauterization.
Because glioma patients are likely to be subjected to radiation,
reoperation, and chemotherapy, every attempt must be made to
handle all tissue layers with the utmost gentleness. The plastic
barrier drape will usually serve to keep the skin towels in
place; if it does not, the towels should be sewn and not clipped
to the skin. If the incision is made in short segments with firm
finger pressure on either side, the use of clips and epinephrine
should keep blood loss at a minimum. It is a common error for
the surgeon to progressively reduce the exposure by placing the
burr holes well within the margins of the scalp incision and
making the dural opening much smaller than the bone flap; this
tendency must be avoided at all costs, because it defeats the
purpose of designing a generous scalp flap in the first place.
Prior to placement of the burr holes, the scalp margins should
be retracted to take maximum advantage of the skin opening. Saw
cuts are made at the outer margin of each burr hole to include
the entire burr hole within the boundaries of the bone flap.
During these manoeuvres, tears in the dura must be avoided,
because they may lead to strangulation of the brain as it herniates through the laceration. When mannitol is to be used,
it should be given as a continuous drip of the 20 percent
solution and not as a bolus; the infusion is usually begun with
the first burr hole and continued until a total dose of 0.5 to
1.0 mg/kg body weight has been achieved. Osteoplastic bone flaps
are preferable in patients likely to be exposed to devitalizing
adjuvant treatments, because the bone is hinged on its own blood
supply; but free flaps are quicker and are the sole option for
parietal lesions. When control of the midline is required and
the sagittal sinus must be crossed, burr holes should be placed
on either side of the sinus; unilateral parietal flaps require
only four holes and are rectangular in shape. Temporal and
frontal flaps must sit low enough to expose the skull base, and
extra burr holes may be required to cross the coronal and
squamosal sutures. It is always useful to place burr holes
directly over the pterion and on the external orbital process
(the "keyhole"), to achieve control of the sphenoid wing and
orbital plate, respectively. The first point of danger is
reached with the dural opening. If the dura feels tight, the
head should be elevated and the neck checked for undue rotation.
If these manoeuvres are unsuccessful, hyperventilation may have
to be increased and mannitol administered. The dura is opened
rapidly to prevent strangulation of the brain in a small
incision, and a decision is made as to whether the herniating
tissue must be resected. If the dura is slack, it is
recommended that it be opened in the following manner. The dural incision is planned to take maximal advantage of the bony
opening, and the base of the dural flap is placed in the
direction of the structures to be protected. In a frontoparietal
exposure, for example, the apex of the incision points forward
and the limbs are drawn backward toward the unexposed motor
cortex; in a parietal exposure, the base is toward the sagittal
sinus; and so forth. A dural stitch is first placed in the
longest side of the intended incision, and a no.11 blade is
used to just nick the dura; the knife is employed with its
cutting edge up, so that inadvertent laceration of the cortex is
nearly impossible, and narrow cottonoid strips (4-in. width)
are immediately inserted to depress the brain from the dura.
Advancement of the strip under the dura is much easier if it is
floated by intermittent irrigation from a miniature irrigating
bulb. The rest of the dura is then opened with small Metzenbaum
scissors reserved only for this purpose. Once adequate control
of the midline, the temporal fossa, the orbital plate, and other
anatomic landmarks has been obtained, the further and
unnecessary exposure of cortex not pertinent to the procedure
should be avoided.
The general location of the cortical incision is
chosen prior to the design of the scalp incision and the bone
flap. Tumors located superficially in the hemisphere are usually
approached directly through the overlying cortex,
and those deep in the hemisphere are often reached through a paramedian approach. At all times, the approximate
location of the motor strip and all language areas must be
known. A useful rule is to draw a line from the pterion to a
point 2 in. behind the coronal suture in the midline and at a
45-degree angle to the orbital plate; the motor strip can be
expected to lie along this line, and Broca's area just posterior
to it in the inferior frontal gyrus. The dominant angular gyrus
is usually located just above the ear. When the cortical
incision must be made in the vicinity of the motor strip, it
should be drawn at an acute angle to the 45-degree line, cutting
across the motor homunculus at a single point; the incision
should always be drawn toward the motor strip and never along
its long axis. The approximate location of the motor strip can
also be determined through use of the Taylor-Haughton lines and
by noticing that the initial segment of the middle meningeal
artery at the pterion usually points in the direction of the
45-degree line. It is useful to keep eloquent cortex covered by
a large cottonoid throughout the operation and to run the free
edge of the cottonoid along the long axis of the motor strip.
The average length of the
cortical incision is 2 to 3 cm, and it is made with the aid of a
two-point suction cautery; such as the Scarff modification of
the original Greenwood bipolar forceps. The instrument combines
the advantages of restricted bipolar coagulation with suction
at the tips of a bayonet forceps that also can be used for
grasping; as a consequence, the other hand is free to hold
another bayonet forceps or a microdissector or microscissors.
Although the initial subpial incision for lobectomies is made
with the unaided eye, it is preferable to use the operating microscope
in making the small cortical incisions required for deep
hemispheric work in critical areas. The suction of the two-point cautery is pinched off and the cautery used to paint the
incision on the pial surface; the incision is opened with the
no.11 blade and large microscissors. The incision is deepened
by spreading with the two-point forceps; no cortical plug is resected. Tapered Sugita blades are attached to a Leyla
self-retaining retractor, and the lips of the cortical incision
are gently spread apart; the blades are always oriented parallel
to the long axis of the incision, because a transverse
orientation tends to cut into the brain and produce subpial
hemorrhage. At this point, use of the operating microscope is
absolutely essential, because a 5- to 8-cm tumor cannot be
gently and safely removed through a 2-cm incision without it.
The length of the cortical tunnel can be shortened by using the
microscope to make an approach through a sulcus, a fissure, or
the crown of a gyrus.
The improved illumination
provided by the microscope readily permits exploration of a
large space through a narrow aperture and facilitates the
delineation of edematous white matter from either a low-grade
glioma or the peripheral fringe of a glioblastoma. Resection of
the tumor must be restricted to those areas of tissue that are
clearly abnormal by virtue of their altered consistency,
texture, or colour. Most soft tumors can be resected with just
the large twopoint suction cautery, a large microscissors for
cutting coagulated blood vessels, and a large microFreer
dissector for establishing planes. Firm areas in fresh
oligodendrogliomas, calcified astrocytomas, or previously
irradiated glioblastomas are best handled with the carbon
dioxide laser. With the two-point suction cautery in one hand and the micromanipulator of the laser in
the other, it is possible to gently and efficiently remove large
tumors with a minimum loss of blood. Small vessels are
coagulated by the laser and large ones by the two-point suction cautery; the laser can be used to transect coagulated vessels as
well as to vaporize the tumor on the edges of the resection
field. When the low-power laser is used at 30 watts, the suction
of the two-point cautery is sufficiently strong to keep the
microsurgical field clear of smoke. As soon as edematous white
matter is reached, fluid can be seen to glisten under the
illumination of the microscope, and in some areas, actual
weeping of the tissue will be observed. Throughout the resection,
the size of the cavity should be measured along its major axes
and these measurements compared with radiographic determinations
made by CT or MRI; it goes without saying that both the actual
scans and the measurements should be immediately available on
the viewer of the operating theatre.
At the conclusion of the resection, scrupulous
haemostasis must be obtained through patient irrigation of the
field and liberal use of the two-point suction cautery. The
return from the irrigating fluid should be crystal clear prior
to the use of oxidized cellulose or microfibrillary collagen to
line the walls of the cavity. The oxidized cellulose should be
laid down in thin wisps so as not to decrease the size of the
resection cavity; because gelatine sponge swells and because it
does not provide as satisfactory a surface for platelet
adhesion, it is better to avoid leaving it in tumor resection beds.
When the self-retaining retractor blades are removed, the two
edges of the cortical incision should just come to rest against
each other without any obvious holes or bruises in the cortical
surface. The dura is always closed in a watertight fashion, and
the bone flap is secured with heavy silk sutures. The scalp is
closed in layers, with a closed drainage system inserted into
the subgaleal space. Perioperative antibiotic coverage, as well as soaking the bone
flap in an iodine solution during the operation and using iodine
irrigation liberally after the dura is closed are routine
measures.
When radical intratumoral
resection is not feasible, normal brain may have to be
sacrificed in order to achieve decompression; under these
unfortunate circumstances, frontal lobectomy becomes the
procedure of choice. Lobectomies are always carried out as
subpial resections in which the pial envelope is
circumferentially incised at the point of amputation and every
attempt is made to avoid repeated violation of the pial surface
at other points. The frontal lobe is removed along a 45-degree
plane with its base at the edge of the sphenoid wing and its
superior edge more posteriorly placed along the upper surface of
the lobe. In this fashion it is possible to avoid entering the
frontal horn and endangering either the thalamus or the basal
ganglia. Since the main trunk of the anterior cerebral artery
winds tightly around the rostrum of the corpus callosum, this
structure is usually not visualized and all major frontal
arteries may be sacrificed with impunity. Concerning the
temporal lobe, it is always safer to carry out lobectomies in
the anterior and inferior portions of the lobe. The inferior and
middle temporal gyri, as well as those areas medially located
along the edge of the tentorium, are always safe to remove. The
dominant superior temporal gyrus should not be removed any
farther posteriorly than 5 cm back from the temporal tip;
remember that the temporal pole is hidden under the edge of the
sphenoid wing and that the measurement must be made from there.
It is sometimes easier to free the tentorial edge under the
operating microscope, and every temporal lobectomy should
conclude with removal of the most medial aspects of the temporal
lobe, a manoeuvre that is sure to prevent most midnight surprises.